PHYS 350 - 2005W [Week 10]

Navigation BarHome PageSyllabusBibliographyProblem SetsNewsContact Info

By week:

You can find the lecture notes at this link or at the Wiki.

Week 10 - Strings and Membranes [9] [11]

Summary

How can we generalize our techniques to systems with an infinite number of degrees of freedom (fields)?

Problem Set - 25 November 2005 Answers

Problem 1 - Steel Drum Top

A steel drum consists of the sawed off bottom of a steel barrel. The bottom of the barrel is hammered into a portion of a sphere. Bumps of various sizes are hammered into the spherical surface.

Check out this link for more information.

What changes would you make to the analysis of membranes that we presented in class?

Problem 2 - A Real Drum Top

In class we analyzed the modes of oscillation of a drum with a square membrane. In reality most drums are round. Write the equation of motion of the membrane in cylindrical coordinates and substitute a trial solution of
z(r,θ t) = R(r) f(θ) g(t)
You should get a differential equation for the three functions. For the square-top drum head the three functions were all sines and cosines. Here you will get something different.

To solve the differential equations, divide both sides of the equation of motion by the trial solution z(r,θ t). You should find that the second derivative of f divided by f is a constant (not a function of f) - similarly for g. What types of functions satisfy these formulae? Now you know f(θ) and g(t).

For the final function we have
1
R(r)
/
|
\
d2 R(r)
d r2
+ 1
r
d R(r)
d r
\
|
/
= -A2 + n2
r2

This differential equation has the solution
R(r) = Jn ( A r )
where J is a Bessel Function of the First Kind.

What is the significance of the constant A? If I hit the drum in the exact center, what is the ratio of the frequency of the second and first harmonic to the fundamental? Is it 5:3:1 like when I pluck a string in the middle or hit a square drum in the middle? What if I hit the drum in a random spot?

Use the website above (and here) to figure this out.

Draw nodal diagrams for the fundamental and first two overtones in both cases.

Reading List

  • ``Classical Mechanics''
    REF: Goldstein, H. 1980, Chapter 12 up to page 562. Top

Last modified: Wednesday, 30 November 2005 12:14:25